The good guy is the problem
The card.
She says what he did, and a man whose name she never mentioned starts talking about himself. “I’d never do that.” His buddy has a variation. “I’m not like that.” Somebody who has spent the whole conversation looking at his phone finally looks up. “Not all men.”
That’s the good-guy card. You show it, the men around you agree you’re a decent guy, and suddenly you’ve done your bit. She still has to work with him tomorrow.
Everybody has one.
In Tagart Cain Sobotka’s online experiments, men tended to believe most other men were more sexist than they were. Ask a roomful of men where the problem is and watch how fast they point past each other. Read the study materials on Figshare.
The guy she reported has a good column too. He’s got himself in it. He’s got a couple of friends who’ll tell you he belongs there, especially if you ask them what he’s like when women are out of the room.
The card is the cover.
Lucy De Souza and Toni Schmader found that men and women underestimated how much men privately cared about gender bias in STEM. Among men especially worried about proving their masculinity, assuming other men didn’t care predicted less willingness to intervene. In a separate experiment, people spoke up more often after they saw somebody else challenge sexism. Read the study on PubMed.
Every good guy waits for another good guy to go first. The man who made the joke looks around and takes the silence as agreement. He tells another joke next week. By then he knows how much room he has, because we’ve spent a week showing him.
What standing apart means.
When your friend makes the joke, let him hear it land. Say what was wrong with it while he can still hear you. When somebody asks for a character reference after a finding of harassment, “He’s a good guy” doesn’t belong in your answer. If management gives him a send-off that buries the finding, ask who approved it and what the next employer will be told. Put your own name on the letter that demands a change.
What it costs.
You can lose a friend over this. Monday morning gets awkward when the guy you challenged is the guy who hands out shifts. Some men are risking a seat at lunch. Others are risking the hours that pay their rent. Talk about that before the letter goes anywhere.
We keep survivors’ names and case details out of the campaign. The demands include protection against retaliation for people who report or take part in the process. Each signer decides separately whether we can publish his name. Ten men from the same institution sign the same letter together. Nobody goes first alone.
